Thinking about infrastructure disruption
Dear friends,
Recently we’ve all watched quite a shock wave of tech-based infrastructure disruptions. As commentator Daniel Drasin put it: “vital digital systems that underlie email, transportation and banking failed in unprecedented ways. These incidents have been explained in seemingly plausible terms. But still, one wonders….”
Mainstream media headlined the phenomenon. The New York Times offered A National Meltdown With Nobody at the Help Desk … The Atlantic asked What on Earth is Going On? … The Los Angeles Times wondered Tech outages are piling up. Could AI make them the new normal? …
There’s been a lot of wild suppositions and explanatory narrative-weaving going on in response. Luckily, some interesting perspectives are also surfacing with a more life-affirming transformational feel to them, or at least some substantive understandings. They reach beyond the immediate news into underlying dynamics and possible nuanced responses. Check out these:
1. AI Doesn’t Have to Go Rogue to Break the World
I got this amazing, very accessible article from Daniel Drasin, who introduced it with this: “The author of this essay on AI hacking, Bruce Schneier, has long been one of the world’s leading experts on computer security and is one of today’s most prominent techno-philosophers. The essay is long, but it has far-reaching implications and is well worth a read. You don’t have to be a geek to get the message.”
I, too, found this essay clear, clarifying, and disturbing. I recommend it. It seems to me ever more obvious that we need to freeze AI development as soon as possible, while undertaking a thorough review of the hackability of our major economic, political, governance and communications systems with an eye towards transforming them in ways suggested by Schneier. So much else – even the kind of longterm regenerative and co-intelligent transformations I write about – seem to have lower priority than addressing this, which could spin the whole game totally out of sync so fast that other ideas and conversations suddenly become passe. As you can imagine, is hard for me to say that….
2. Thomas Friedman: We Just Set Off the Second Big Bang (7 minutes long video)
“According to the columnist Tom Friedman, humanity has set off a second Big Bang — and we are not ready for it. In this video, he explains why the rise of artificial intelligence and other ‘godlike’ powers will require us to build healthy interdependencies to survive what comes next.”
Excerpt
“We are going to rise together by building healthy interdependencies. Or we’re going to fall together. But baby, whatever we’re doing, we’re doing it together. We can learn that early. We can learn that late. We can learn that before the massive global crisis or we can learn it after. But learn it we will.”
3. Rethinking critical infrastructure security for the age of AI
The above brief essay – inspired by a Trump administration executive order – showed up in response to a search for “what forms of critical infrastructure are vulnerable to AI disruption?” Obvious answers include the energy grid, transportation, healthcare, public safety, finance, food distribution, water systems, government, military, research, legal and communications infrastructures.
The point is, as AI becomes both more powerful and more deeply embedded in these and all other systems, the systems themselves become more vulnerable to both error and ill will by both human and AI agents, with real world impacts that are often more far-reaching, fast-moving, complex, puzzling and solution-resistant than they were before.
The responses currently envisioned in this paper are excellent beginnings – especially with their focus on resilience, speed and cooperation. But I notice the paper does not address the need to halt (or, at least, slow) the development of greater AI power to provide time to develop the infrastructure and responsive capacity that the essay envisions. For an urgent response, consider the Ban Artificial Superintelligence Act and the petition supporting it.
Yet I found the paper nevertheless valuable regarding the nature of this unprecedented challenge and the complexity involved in even minimal responses to it.
4. Prepare for the AI Apocalypse Like You’d Prepare for a Snowstorm: Water, batteries, and go bags
This essay is current and good, as far as it goes, but is surprisingly shallow. It reminds me of the official Cold War advice to citizens on how to prepare for a nuclear war (e.g., “duck and cover” under your desk). I curated far better – and more transformational – resources, advice and visions in my 1998-1999 work on community preparedness for Y2K disruptions.
Yet today I found – hidden in all the superficial but useful advice about personal prepping – a profound gem of guidance: “The most important thing … is to befriend—and plan alongside—your neighbors, as connectedness is one of the strongest predictors of how communities do in the aftermath of a disaster.”
That’s what we concluded back in 1998. For example, you can check out my post The Year 2000 Problem and Sustainability: Rediscovering Nature and Neighbors through Y2K which celebrates interdependence and envisions community solutions to most of the challenges of infrastructure disruption (see the PS below for an excerpt). If you are curious or ambitious, you might explore my large and oddly still relevant Y2K website starting at its homepage.
5. I found an interesting overview of the Trump administration’s response to all this in The Atlantic’s The Limits of Positive Thinking: Trump is acting like there’s no problem. Persistent outages tell a different story.
This essay includes a significant data point: “The FBI warned this week about an AI-enabled tool set, called ARTEX, that ‘cybercriminals and state-aligned hackers’ are using to identify weakness and develop attacks in under three hours. None of the affected companies has said that it thinks its systems went down because of an attack. But security experts told us that in the past few weeks, they have been struggling to keep up with an onslaught of attempted hacks from AI-enabled adversaries. And rushing to harden lots of computer infrastructure all at once can be messy and inconsistent, explaining some of the disruptions.”
—
In the midst of all this (which keeps changing daily), I find myself shaking my head: “Ah! The blessings, the curses, the uncertainties and opportunities we find dancing in and around our modern dependence on advanced technology – a dependence that I unfortunately share!” As I witness the uncomfortable irony of it, I want so much to get back to my work on the dynamics of regenerativity….
But I’d better get this posted while I can….
Coheartedly,
Tom
PS: Back in 1998-99 I developed the world’s leading website about using Y2K for personal and social transformation. (I couldn’t find another comparable site anywhere…) But I hadn’t read my The Year 2000 Problem and Sustainability: Rediscovering Nature and Neighbors through Y2K essay since 2000 and was startled by its vision. For me, the current AI-related infrastructure shocks and risks strongly hark back to Y2K and some of our efforts to ride its possible tsunami of change towards “sustainability”.
Excerpt
An interdependence covenant for thriving through infrastructure disruptions
We have come to understand that our primary form of interdependence is with neighbors and nature. This fact has been hidden from us by our dependence on the technological industrial infrastructure — the network of roads, stores, wires, pipes, buildings and institutions into which we are woven by the monetary economy, and which is so ubiquitous that we barely realize that it is one single complex system.
Y2K has made this system visible, and shown us our dependence on it. As we contemplate losing the daily support of this infrastructure, we realize we have become addicted to it. That addiction has shaped us into consumers, producers, managers and investors — dessicating our lives as neighbors, citizens and practitioners of our full humanity and selfhood. Realizing this now, we are ready to recover our full lives.
We see how our infrastructure-dependent culture has degraded nature into ‘natural resources,’ ‘raw materials’ and ‘the environment’ — rather than what it really is: our home in the family of Life. We have lost the wisdom, humility and self-reliance that come from informed kinship with the natural world. Our infrastructure addiction has led us to repeatedly harm each other and nature without even knowing we’re doing it. Realizing this now, we are ready to recover our partnership with the world.
We recognize that our dependence on this infrastructure and on technology has been deceptively promoted and experienced as personal independence. But we aren’t independent. Our unacknowledged dependence on this infrastructure camouflages our more essential, ongoing interdependence with nature and with each other. Realizing this now, we are ready to wake up to our real place in the world.
As awakening individuals, we are now ready to deal with our addiction to the infrastructure and its seductive illusion of independence. We are ready to build more meaningful lives, sharing gifts with our natural and human communities.
We seek together to progressively replace our unconscious infrastructure addiction with conscious interdependence and partnership with nature and neighbor. We seek to pursue our full humanity — in our lives and in our communities. We seek to expand our roles as neighbors, bioregional and planetary citizens and whole human beings — while decreasing our roles as consumers, producers, managers and investors in the mass economy. We realize we can only do this to the extent we help our communities do this, and that this will be an ongoing exploration together, forever.
– – –
The essay then goes on to provide extensive guidance and possibilities to manifest Friedman’s “healthy interdependence” in our local communities as a creative transformational response to the threat of Y2K collapse (or now AI infrastructure disruptions).
I’d forgotten I’d written both the covenant above and the detailed visionary guidance that followed it. Today, there’s a lot more I could add to the “collective intelligence” section of the essay, but I think my 2017 wise democracy pattern language can serve as a “collective intelligence” update for today’s readers ….
We greatly value your heartfelt support!
Please donate HERE.
A note about donations: We’re working to bring our registration up to date with the California Attorney General. While we do so, we’re not currently soliciting or accepting donations from California residents. However, we welcome donations from all the rest of you. And we warmly appreciate everyone’s patience and support!
Tom Atlee, The Co-Intelligence Institute, POB 493, Eugene, OR 97440
Appreciating, evoking and engaging the wisdom and resourcefulness of the whole on behalf of the whole
*** Visit the Wise Democracy Pattern Language Project ***
*** Buy a Wise Democracy Pattern Card Deck ***
Read
- CO-INTELLIGENCE
- EMPOWERING PUBLIC WISDOM
- PARTICIPATORY SUSTAINABILITY
- THE TAO OF DEMOCRACY
- REFLECTIONS ON EVOLUTIONARY ACTIVISM
Please support our work.
Leave a Reply